Glove Buying Guide

Glove Buying Guide

In baseball and softball, a fielding glove is one of the most important tools you’ll need to become a successful player. In a lot of ways, it’s the final piece to that spectacular diving catch in the outfield or what you need to stop that line drive down the third base line. Not all gloves are created equal in terms of size and material. What size baseball glove or softball glove you should use largely depends on the position you play, but there are also other factors that help determine exactly which glove you should equip yourself with.

In this guide, we will cover:

Parts of a Baseball/Softball Glove

There are four major important parts to a baseball or softball glove and they are specified below:

When buying a glove, there are a few basic terms that have to be defined first:

  • Type of throw - Refers to which hand a player uses to throw the ball (not which hand the glove is on), depending on if the player is a righty or a lefty.
  • RHT - Right hand thrower. Means the player throws with his or her right hand and wears the glove on the left.
  • LHT - Left hand thrower. Means the player throws with his or her left hand and wears the glove on the right.

Guidelines for Selecting a Glove

We’ve already mentioned that the best glove for you depends on which position you play. But there are other factors as well:

  • Pocket size - The pocket size of an outfielder’s glove is bigger than that of a middle infielder, allowing outfielders to catch fly balls with more ease. Shortstops and second baseman usually have a shallower pocket, which allows them to get the ball out of the glove quicker, especially on double plays.
  • Webbing - There are different types of webbings found in gloves for baseball and softball players including, but not limited to: I-web, Basket web, Closed web, Single Post web, Dual Post web, Modified Trapeze web, and Trapeze web. The type of webbing most common for infielders contains a looser stitch which gives more control in hopes of getting the ball out quicker - it also doesn’t pick up large clumps of dirt with it. Traditionally, there are eight different kinds of webbings to choose from:
  • Closed Web

    Dual Post Web

    Modified Trapeze Web

    Trapeze Web

    Single Post Web

    Two-Piece Closed Web

    Basket Web

    I-Web

  • Padding - Padding preference is another thing to consider. The amount of padding you have on your glove depends on the position you play. Catcher’s mitts feature more padding to protect their hands from pitchers’ throws. Other positions, such as first and third base, may also need more padding. Recently, the popularity of extra wrist padding has grown, especially at the corner infield positions.
  • Wrist Adjustments - Some gloves are made with wrist adjustments that allow players to make the glove fit snug to their hand, allowing them to put on and take off the glove with ease. These can either be Velcro, a buckle system, laced, or a D-ring fastener.
  • Material - Gloves can be made of many different types of materials including leather, synthetic materials, mesh, and treated leather. Leather is the preferred material among players due to their durability and comfort. Players may opt for treated leather gloves which is pre-conditioned with oils for quicker break in period. Some prefer a mesh backed glove for a lighter glove. For younger players, a synthetic glove is good it's the lightest and most inexpensive glove available.

Baseball Gloves

Certain positions require a baseball glove with a particular webbing. Check out the list below for common webbings you'll find for each position:

  • Outfielders - H-web, modified trapeze or trapeze - bigger, deeper pockets
  • Middle infielders - I-web, single post, 2-piece closed - stay shallow
  • 3rd basemen - dual post, modified trapeze, closed webs - stronger, deeper pockets
  • Pitcher - basket, 2-piece closed, one-piece closed, modified trapeze - conceal stitches when selecting a pitch

Fastpitch Gloves

Like baseball gloves, positions in fastpitch softball require a specific webbing:

  • Middle infielders, first base, and some outfielders – open web that allows for quicker transfer to throwing hand
  • Pitchers, third base, and some outfielders – closed web that provides more support for outfielders and shields ball in pitchers glove

Proper Way to Measure a Baseball/Softball Glove

When trying to find out how long a glove is, you can look on the thumb or pinky finger and you should see the size etched in the leather there. The sizes range from 8 to 15 inches, and to 35 inches for catcher’s mitts. To measure a glove that does not have a size, take a fabric tape measure and measure from the top of the index finger, down along the glove, to the center of the heel of the glove:

Now that you know how to measure the glove, you can use that measurement and reference our baseball glove sizing chart to determine how to a size a baseball glove for your position and age group. If you’re looking for youth baseball glove sizing guidance, you can follow the same chart.

Differences Between Gloves By Position

One of the most important things to keep in mind when it comes to buying a glove is the different styles and types you can choose from. With each glove, you will have different types of webs and pockets, and the choice of the best glove for you depends on the position you play.

The charts below show an estimate of the size range of the glove for a specific player for both baseball and softball:

Baseball Glove Sizing Chart by Position

Age Catcher First Base Second Base / Short Stop Third Base Pitcher Outfield
Under 7 29.5 - 30" 11.5" 8-10.5" 8-10.5" 8-10.5" 9-10.5"
8 - 10 30-31" 11.5-12" 10.5-11.25" 10.5-11.5" 10.5-11.5" 10-12"
11 - 13 30-32.5" 11.5-12" 11-11.5" 11-11.75" 11.5-12" 11.75-12.75"
Over 14 32-34.5" 12-13" 11.25-11.5" 11.5-12" 11.5-12" 12-13"

Baseball Glove Sizing Chart by Position

Age Catcher First Base Second Base / Short Stop Third Base Pitcher Outfield
Under 7 29.5 - 30" 11.5" 8-10.5" 8-10.5" 8-10.5" 9-11"
8 - 10 30-32" 11.5-12" 10.5-11.25" 10.5-11.5" 10.5-11.5" 10-12"
11 - 13 31-.32.5" 12-13" 11.25-12" 11.75-12.5" 11.5-12.5" 11.75-12.5"
Over 14 33-35" 12-13" 11.5-12.5" 11.75-12.5" 11.5-12.5" 12-13"

Slowpitch Softball Glove Sizing Chart by Position

First Base Second Base / Shortstop Third Base Pitcher Outfield
12-13" 11.5-12.5" 11.75-13" 11.5-13" 12-15"

Youth vs. Adult gloves

A youth glove is designed for younger players with smaller hands. They are typically cheaper than the adult gloves and are much easier to close. The youth gloves are not made of the same high quality leather, but the materials they are made of make them easier to close. Youth gloves have smaller, narrower fingers and should be used for a player under 10 years old. They sometimes can be used for a player up to 12 years old, but after then, kids should be using adult gloves. To fit an adult glove onto a younger player’s hand, the back of the wrist can be tightened. This is done on softball gloves with a Velcro strap, but on baseball gloves, the glove needs a minor re-lacing. The picture below shows the difference of how a tightened glove looks compared to a non-adjusted one.

Catcher’s MITTS

A catcher’s glove is more commonly referred to as a catcher’s mitt because it does not have separately cut fingers like other positions. This allows catchers to catch fastballs for an entire game without wearing down quickly or the catches becoming painful. For this reason, catchers’ mitts tend to be very stiff right off the shelf and take a while to break in. Many catchers buy their replacement mitt a few months before they think their old mitt will wear out so they have time to break their new glove in. Catcher mitts tend to have a closed pocket because they can be attached with the most lacing and take the most abuse without breaking.

There is a difference between baseball and softball catcher’s mitts. The softball catcher’s mitt has a deeper pocket and thinner side walls to accommodate for the bigger ball. Catcher’s mitts are also measured differently. Instead of the standard measuring, they are measured around the circumference of the glove to capture the entire catching area of the mitt. The standard size range is from 29.5 to 34.5 inches for baseball and from 29.5 to 35 inches for softball.

Mizuno Pro Limited Edition GMP200 Baseball Catcher's Mitt All-Star Vela Dual-Pro CMW4000 33" Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt

Mizuno Pro Limited Edition GMP200 Baseball Catcher's Mitt

All-Star Vela Dual-Pro CMW4000 33" Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt

First Basemen’s Gloves

A first baseman’s glove is very similar to the catcher’s mitt with the exception that it is longer and doesn’t have as much padding. It’s designed to have the same catching area as a catcher’s glove, but is flexible for scooping throws out of the dirt. The first basemen’s glove is stronger than a standard glove so that the fingers do not flop back like a regular fielder’s glove would. They also have open web designs to allow the pocket to be a little deeper and lighter than a closed pocket. First basemen’s gloves normally start being worn at age 10 or older, because it can be difficult for younger kids to close the big glove. The typical size range for both baseball and softball is from 11.5 to 13 inches.


Mizuno Pro Limited Edition GMP3000BK 13" Baseball First Base Mitt

Louisville Slugger Xeno Pro FGXPBN5-FBM1 13

Pitchers’s Gloves

These gloves won’t have as much padding as other gloves and instead rely on being comfortable. They’re usually larger than other gloves to allow pitchers to move their hands around to grip the ball and hide their hand movements from the batter before a pitch. A pitcher doesn’t need to be as worried as other players about the performance of their glove. But the comfort is important since they are constantly catching and will often have to stop line drives hit back through the middle. It’s also important to make sure the glove isn’t too heavy. Many manufacturers make light versions of high-end gloves with special materials that weigh significantly less than standard gloves.

Wilson A2000 CK22GM Clayton Kershaw Model 11.75

Wilson A2000 CK22GM Clayton Kershaw Model 11.75

Infield Gloves

These smaller gloves are made to allow for quick plays like a double play in the middle infield. They are shorter and have a shallower pocket than other gloves. Infielders typically want an open pocket that makes it easy to get the ball out quickly. This is typically an I-web, post web, Dual Post web, or modified trapeze pocket. The only position that sometimes wants a closed pocket is third base. This is because third base gets harder hits that a closed pocket can handle better than an open one will. The standard size for a baseball infield glove is 11.25 to 12 inches, and 11.5 to 12.5 inches for softball. For softball players, there aren’t as many selections in terms of webs because of the large ball, so the choices will be limited. .


Wilson A2000 EL3GM Evan Longoria Model 11.75

Wilson A2000 DP15SP Dustin Pedroia Model 11.5

Outfield Gloves

These larger gloves are made for diving catches and to catch fly balls. This means that the gloves are longer and deeper with extra support in the fingers. The pocket designs for baseball are typically open with the main options being a modified trapeze and an H-web. These pockets are the best for long extension plays that need to keep the ball in the glove, such as diving plays and snow cones. For softball, the pockets can be closed webs, because they need to be extra deep to account for the size of the softball. The typical size of an outfielder’s glove is 9 to 15 inches for baseball and 9 to 15 inches for softball.


Rawlings RGG1275H Gold Glove 12.75 Adult Baseball Glove

Once you’ve purchased your new glove, visit our other guides to learn how to break in and care for your new glove! Be sure to check our online store to get your new baseball or softball glove today.

Compare Products

You have no items to compare.

Share